Fish ID

[lazoman]

Friend forwarded this pic to me, interested in how folks ID them.

 

[Dogbreath]

Yup those are Salmon great eating fish smoke up real good.[8D]

 

[new generation]

The top small one is a pink,small scales that rub off with your hand and large oval dots on tail.Middle fish looks like a coho,black tail no spots and white gums,bottom fish,again looks like a coho,black tail and white gums and is also a hatchery.No chinooks because they have black tail with lots of small gold circles and black gums with lots of teeth.

 

[yammy5]

Three coho, two with adipose fins. Top one could be a pink I suppose. Tough to tell but the scales do look like a pink.

 

[walleyes]

quote:3 pound humpy and two ratty hoe's......The one nice looking thing in this pic is that global knife,good choice in a blade!

ahhhh thats a good one....

 

[SerengetiGuide]

You can definitely see oval spots on the one in the middle, or at least it looks that way.... Top one a pink...bottom one hard to tell...it's a bad angle the photo was taken from in my opinion.

 

[salmon9]

First is a pink and two cohos. Bottom coho is a hatchery.

 

[walleyes]

K... I got to put the rep on the line here,, my first instinct was pink and two chinook and thats what my story is,, sorry mom if I'm wrong....

 

[lazoman]

My opinion exactly, pink and two coho. He though the bottom was a spring, from the difference in the darker mouth colour, larger maxillary size, and squarer tail. The are covered in gravel from the beach making for a bad photo, and yes looks like a good blade!

 

[new generation]

Click on the pedder winters topic and you will see what a chinook looks like in the fish box.....

 

[wolf]

Small humpy.Wild coho,then a Hatchery coho. Bad IDs yammy and walleyes

 

[Pablo2079]

The top "humpy" doesn't look right to me.... the tail (not enough large oval spots) and the eye (a little big). The bottom two definitely look like hoes though.

 

[cletus]

All three look like coho to me.

 

[Klob]

Humpin Hoes

 

[tortuga]

IMO Cletus wins. If that top one was a humpy it would have black lips and smaller scales

 

[walleyes]

Doohhh,, ohh why does everything have to be so hard [B)] [B)]

 

[Captain Dudds]

the top one is hands down a humpy and the others are coconuts. For the pink, the scales are tiny and have mostly come off - and just sort of the general look of it - definately a humpy.

 

[walleyes]

Ok I got em pegged now..

Top one is a Bar-B-Qer..
Middle one is a fryer..
Bottom one a smoker..

Now thats my final offer

 

[Striper Sniper]

I am with Walleyes! SS

 

[blueorca]

Looks like they should been released to me