Federal whale-saving efforts threaten Vancouver Island livelihoods, say groups

Whole in the Water

Well-Known Member
Great to see some media coverage about how the Feds are hurting the rec sector and the economy it supports. Kudos for a good job for the folks who stepped up to do this, including Ryan Chamberland, new South Island SFAB chair. We need this and more of it in times to come to raise public awareness of the all the issues re. protecting SRKW's.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/federal-whale-saving-efforts-threaten-vancouver-island-livelihoods-say-groups-1.4936116

Federal whale-saving efforts threaten Vancouver Island livelihoods, say groups
Federal government efforts to save threatened southern resident killer whales could endanger the survival of communities on Vancouver Island whose economies depend on sport fishing and tourism revenues, a coalition of tourism, business and recreational fishing groups said Thursday.
About two dozen leaders gathered at a popular sport fishing marina near Victoria to warn the federal government almost 10,000 jobs are at stake as well as the futures of several cities, towns and villages on the Island that base their incomes on fishing and tourism.

The coalition calls itself Thriving Orcas, Thriving Communities and said the federal government has extended a 5,000 square kilometre critical habitat zone off the southwest coast of Vancouver Island that could result in fishing closures to protect the whales, whose population stands at 74.

Sport fishing an anchor industry: advocate
Val Litwin, president of the B.C. Chamber of Commerce, said 18 communities have come together to form the coalition.

Karl Ablack of the Port Renfrew Chamber of Commerce said recreational fishing generates almost $1 billion for the B.C. economy and employs more than 8,400 people.

He said Port Renfrew, located about 100 kilometres northwest of Victoria, has transformed itself from a struggling forest-dependent community to a vibrant sport fishing destination.

"The strength of our local economy is now based and primarily dependent upon our anchor industry, which is the sport and recreational fishing industry," said Ablack.

"It will, without question, economically devastate our community as well as other coastal communities on Vancouver Island."

Bookings down: lodge operator
Ryan Chamberland, a fishing lodge operator in the Sooke area, said sport fishing closures last year in his region near Victoria hurt businesses and fishing operators. He said charter bookings for the coming season are already down up to 80 per cent.

"The people who operate regularly in these areas know that there's room for both of us in our coastal waters," he added.


whale-protection-economy-20181206.jpg
British Columbia Chamber of Commerce president Val Litwin addresses a news conference in Esquimalt, B.C., Thursday, Dec.6, 2018. Sportfishing, tourism and business leaders from across Vancouver Island said the possibility of extended federal fishing closures to protect threatened southern resident killer whales endangers their livelihoods. (Dirk Meissner/Canadian Press )
A Fisheries and Oceans Canada report this year said the killer whale recovery strategy aims to "ensure the long-term viability of resident killer whale populations by achieving and maintaining demographic conditions that preserve their reproductive potential, genetic variation and cultural continuity."

The report cites four principal objectives: ensure adequate food supply, limit pollution, reduce noise disturbance and protect and identify areas for protection and critical habitat.
 
It has to be delivered very carefully so the general public does not view sport fisher's as a greedy bunch
looking after their own interests while the whales starve.
That is how the ENGO'S are portraying us.
 
Agreed. The campaign leaders should reach out to the media and clarify their stance on this. This may get lost in the pre-Xmas chaos but would set the tone for future media coverage.
 
The message should be loud and clear: sportfishing does NOT harm orcas and closing sportfishing will not help protecting orcas. Period.
 
Similar article in today's TC. The reporter gave the last word to someone from the Suzuki Foundation.
 
Another Chamber release. http://www.bcchamber.org/advocacy-n...t-marine-based-tourism-following-federal-srkw And as to your question fishbadger---- start writing letters to the Minister, your MP, the RDG of DFO, and your MLA with copies to the press as well. Start asking the sport fish retailers in your area if they have written a letter to DFO etc- they have as much or more to lose as we do.... but they need to get reminded of that...
 
I see a lot of "They", "He", "She" but maybe it should be a little of bit "I" . If we don't all get involved it may just be an impossible task for a very few ..... Send a text, email, letter or ...... something, to the DFO, Your MP, we all need to get involved.

 
How can we, Joe Public, help?

fb


Letters help as politicians do want votes however I'd suggest also a more direct bang for your buck by donating to the "Thriving Orcas, Thriving Communities outreach GoFundMe campaign. https://www.gofundme.com/orcaoutreachfund
Building strength of our voice via funding for the group that is on the 'front line' fighting for us ...
alternatively or as well, an SFI donation https://sportfishing.bc.ca/donate/

...... and post videos such as the one below to all your social media accounts to bring awareness to as much as the general public as possible :

https://www.sportfishingbc.com/foru...-presentation-srkw-update-nov-6th-2018.72438/
 
Last edited:
Letters help as politicians do want votes however I'd suggest also a more direct bang for your buck by donating to the "Thriving Orcas, Thriving Communities outreach GoFundMe campaign. https://www.gofundme.com/orcaoutreachfund
Building strength of our voice via funding for the group that is on the 'front line' fighting for us ...
alternatively or as well, an SFI donation https://sportfishing.bc.ca/donate/

...... and post videos such as the one below to all your social media accounts to bring awareness to as much as the general public as possible :

https://www.sportfishingbc.com/foru...-presentation-srkw-update-nov-6th-2018.72438/

Thanks, yes getting behind groups trying to get our message out is a great way to make a difference. So far we have 2 websites running - we would appreciate people visiting and sharing links to them with friends:

www.srkw.org/
and
www.orcawhales.org/

Plus you can follow us on Facebook and Instagram - the more shares and likes the better. Our aim is to help shift the public narrative on this issue, to get some facts out and offer alternative approaches to the sorts of management measures that we saw implemented that closed recreational fishing. Our firm belief is there are science-based management options that protect whales, while allowing responsible marine use of the same habitat. We can co-exist with whales without impacting their ability to successfully acquire prey.

www.facebook.com/bcorcawhales/
www.instagram.com/p/Bqs4q2Dneva/

We will continue to work with partners to build on the Thriving Orca's, Thriving Communities Coalition outreach. An important aspect is to speak with community leaders about the social and economic value/benefits their communities receive from the Recreational fishery.
 
Last edited:
Doing our best to counter all the negative social media coming from the ENGO sector. They are extremely well funded, have paid staff, and don’t seem to mind putting out half truths in their posts. Thanks everyone for your help and support.
 
Back
Top