Yeah I've been using small herring I dipped at work so far, about 3.5-5". They look small and I have to troll a lil faster to make em' roll the way I want, but they were doin 2/1 against the the Rhys Davis chovys I had running on the other side. Most guys would look at them and laugh because most of them are missing a lot of scales, but they keep catching, so I keep rolling them.