So far they seem to be OK. Nice thing is they aren't damaging my rod handles like the scotty orca's were. Fairly easy to get out and they lock the rod in place so it can't move until you lift it from the front. I loved the concept of the orca design, but found it had 2 flaws. First was the cork handle was really pressed into a hard plastic holder creating damage to the cork. Second, the reverse side of the holder meant the pressure on the rod wants to open the orca and on earlier versions it could release unexpectedly.