Times Colonist: For the sake of orcas, don’t hook a chinook

Discussion in 'Conservation, Fishery Politics and Management.' started by jriptide, Jul 14, 2019.

  1. jriptide

    jriptide Member

    Yet another misguided article in the Times Colonist, calling for Sportfisherman not to fish when the closures are lifted.

    https://www.timescolonist.com/opini...sake-of-orcas-don-t-hook-a-chinook-1.23884505

    I have lost a lot of respect for the David Suzuki Foundation. Even the title " don't hook a Chinook" says a lot. Why are they not calling for the removal of nets from the Fraser River, which will have a far greater impact on restoring salmon runs. In addition they bring up concerns over the missing orca, without also pointing out that it believed some of the Orca remain in California waters, where record number of Chinooks are returning to the rivers. No talk of the impacts by pinheads. No talk of the abundance of Chinook being reported from Northern Vancouver Island and Haida Gawaii. Yet given the lack of a serious coordinated response from the sportfishing community, we can bet that closures will only get worse. It would be great if sport fisherman advocates near the Fraser and other rivers starting taking pictures to show the wall of nets that await chinook and post them on social media to make the public aware that sport fishing is not the problem here.
     
    Irishwolf likes this.
  2. SerengetiGuide

    SerengetiGuide Well-Known Member

    Need a rebuttal from SFI
     
    littlechucky likes this.
  3. Original

    Original Well-Known Member

    My rebuttal for tommorows protest. I have also made Check tv aware.
     

    Attached Files:

    Stizzla and wildmanyeah like this.
  4. Spring-time

    Spring-time New Member

    Well opening day up in Campbell River, a couple professional anglers I know released 17 Chinook salmon in a couple hours because they were all too big for the slot limit. It was going on all around them too. There’s no shortage of fish folks, it’s bs. This closure was political pure and simple. Save the orca is misguided, it will turn into save the seals next year. This government is misleading the public. Science is on our side so they’ll simply say whatever they need to in order to push an agenda. Awful, businesses being crippled over this and what will we get out of it? Tax increases and a loss of fishing privileges.
     
    Dave H likes this.
  5. wildmanyeah

    wildmanyeah Crew Member

    Good luck finding a white spring that makes the slot.
     
    littlechucky and Spring-time like this.
  6. SpringVelocity

    SpringVelocity Well-Known Member

    From 2019 at The Outpost in Haida Gwaii. Yeah leave the Chinook alone.

    upload_2019-7-15_10-21-34.png
     
    Last edited: Jul 15, 2019
  7. wildmanyeah

    wildmanyeah Crew Member

    From Facebook Bon chovy


    While the David Suzuki Foundation was putting the final touches on their "Don't hook a chinook" article, David Suzuki himself was up in Haida Gwaii....hooking chinook! What an absolute hypocritical organization and leader. Not only is David Suzuki and his foundation evidently hypocritical, but they are scapegoating the public fishery and FAILING to act in the best interests of threatened Fraser River Chinook Salmon. DNA and Coded Wired Tag Data has PROVEN that marine impacts on threatened 4-2 and 4-2 Fraser chinook are insignificant. With the DFO working around a 0.8 percent explotation rate on threatened Fraser Stocks in recreational and commercial fisheries in marine areas in 2019, it is shameful that the David Suzuki Foundation is clearly ignoring this DFO data in order to mislead the Canadian public. The BC coast is trying to enjoy an excellent year of chinook abundance in quite some time and rightfully so. I am sure David Suzuki himself witnessed the fabulous chinook fishing on his sport fishing vacation during the week of July 5th, 2019.

    Speaking of Fraser River Chinook stocks of concern, the David Suzuki Foundation surely has the DFO data showing that Marine Fisheries have insignificant impacts on 5-2 and 4-2 chinook with management restrictions utilized in recent years. As scientists, why is there no push to halt the daily gill netting in the Fraser River on the exact stocks of concern, or no talk of seal predation on outgoing chinook smolts,or no action on middle/upper Fraser enhancement programs, or no action or talk to push for swift action on Upper Fraser Watersheds in the face of a changing climate. Are they in bed with the Federal Government.. it is becoming very clear. Why are they not celebrating the incredible abundance of chinook overall this year in BC Waters? Save the orcas, save the salmon, and do not listen to the Hypocrital David Suzuki Foundation.

    Georgia Strait Alliance Jonathan Wilkinson Ken Hardie - MP, Fleetwood-Port Kells Todd Doherty, MP
     
  8. littlechucky

    littlechucky Well-Known Member

    What a complete joke.

    Do as I say...not as I do.
     
    wildmanyeah likes this.
  9. islandboy

    islandboy Active Member

    Google "david suzuki exposed". :rolleyes:
     
  10. Birdsnest

    Birdsnest Well-Known Member

    Who is all in that photo? Anyone know?
     
  11. Damien

    Damien Well-Known Member

    David Suzuki, Willie Mitchell and...thats all I got. lol
     
  12. ziggy

    ziggy Well-Known Member

    From Raincoast site.

    Local expedition cruise company Maple Leaf Adventures is committing a 10-year, $100,000 donation to Raincoast Conservation Foundation, starting today. It’s an example of how tourism business and conservation can work hand-in-hand on the British Columbia coast

    Pretty clear what the agenda is here. Eco tourism has bought them off!
     
  13. halimark

    halimark Well-Known Member

    Just a bunch of hypocritical assholes.

    HM
     
  14. littlechucky

    littlechucky Well-Known Member

    So $10,000 per year!

    What a joke.

    How Much do sportfishers contribute?

    It’s time we all donated to SFI and they make a donation on a pass through basis to PSF and make a giant campaign about all the $ the sector donates. I’m sure you could arrange a way to make sure individuals get the tax benefit of their donation.
     
  15. ziggy

    ziggy Well-Known Member

    It’s not the size of the donation I was pointing out, but rather the fact that these two organizations have partnered.
     
  16. littlechucky

    littlechucky Well-Known Member

    Fair enough.

    PSF has a huge number of individual donors who donate $10,000 in any given year.

    I bet most of them are anglers.
     
  17. walleyes

    walleyes Crew Member

  18. SpringVelocity

    SpringVelocity Well-Known Member

    This gets even more interesting. Riddle me this who is that at the far right down. Take a guess.
     
  19. saltcod

    saltcod Active Member

    I got nothing... The guy beside Willie looks familiar
     
  20. Goathorns

    Goathorns Active Member

Share This Page