I've been using the sickle hooks now for several years. I've never had a single sickle siwash hook break. I did get a bad batch of sickle octopus one year and had several of those break one trip off the WCVI. I also haven't had a real problem with those hooks rusting. I'm pretty religous about rinsing all my gear. I keep of bucket of fresh water with lemon joy on the boat and when the gear comes off, in it goes. Seems to really save the gear for me. It also doesn't take much effort to get sharpen the sickles back to super sharp either IMO. I'm a fan of the sickles as they seem to hook up well and really hold hooked fish. In fairness though, lots of you fish far more that I do each year so the wear and tear, rust ect. is likely more much more of an issue for you than it is for me.