quote:Originally posted by SeaFunMan
No one who has the means to afford a computer, Digital camera, 4x4 truck and ATV, gun, gun license (optional), money for fuel and supplies, hunting permit, beer and days off (assumes a job) needs to stock (from the back of a truck?) a wild full grown animal in its’ remote habitat and blast it from a ¼ mile away. Compare this “Sport” to fishing where the goal is to tease a “BITE” from a creature that is intent on killing something its’ self, you just tricked it. No sneaking up, no killing instrument (gun) just a fair playing field. No comparison
Okay....first off Seafun, you are incorrect in that a "gun license" is optional. It is NOT an option in Canada thanks to the federal liberal party. Not sure if you have heard of the "gun registry"??
You obviously have never hunted before and I can respect that. Your perception is not entirely true. What about someone who spend their time "calling" a moose in? That is "enticing" is it not?
What is the problem if I charter a plane to fly in to a remote river system and spend 10 days travelling by canoe and enjoying the wilderness and if I happen to take a moose to provide food for the table, VERY healthy food I may add.
And....everything you stated up above can be easily applied to fishing.
Why would anyone with who has the means to afford a computer, Digital camera, FISHING BOAT and a float tube, fishing rods and gear, fishing license (NOT optional), money for fuel and supplies, boat operators permit, beer and days off (assumes a job) needs to STALK/FOOL/ENTICE (from the safe confines of their boat) the presitgious wild pacific salmon in its’ remote/natural habitat and and yank it up from the safe confines of the ocean, some 100' below the surface??
As you state in "tricking". When I hunt moose AND deer I call or rattle antlers to "entice" them to come in. They are coming in with the intent of
a) kicking my butt and stealing my ladies, IF I have any
b) if I am calling like a gal, well HE knows what HE wants and I am trying to fool him
c) he is responding to my call, to do nothing more than kick my a$$ to show his dominance and get rid of me.
With respect to a bear which WILL respond to calls....would you not say then that MY call to entice a bear in, is bringing him in for what his intention is to eat whatever is making that noise? To kill the source of the noise? So using your logic I guess bear hunting is okay IF a bear responds to a call from me....I have fooled him into wanting to eat me....and "KILL me it's self"??
I think your perception of hunting is quite jaded. I can tell you a story from when I was in University and I had a friend who was studying biology and zoology who was somewhat opposed to hunting. I extended the offer for him to come along with my Dad and I on a 4 day deer hunting trip. He was completely floored at how his perception changed, and what he learned from myself and my father. "Guys I have learned more in 4 days in the bush with you, than I could learn in a classroom". His sterotype (the common perception to a non-hunter) of what he imagined was FAR from the truth.
You seem to have the misconception as to hunting. Sure there are different kinds of folks out there who hunt by different means. There are some folks who like to drive the roads, and it is NOT illegal and they are perfectly fine doing so. For me, it is not my bag....I enjoy hiking and being far away from others. As far as "hunting from the back of a truck"....that is illegal. Sure there are people out there who break the laws and it disgusts "ethical law abiding hunters". But just like with hunting there are bad apples, there are also bad apples who fish.
You have obviously experienced fishing, as you are on this forum. Would you not find it offensive if I were to stero-type fisherman as a bunch of fat slobs, who sit in the front of their bass boat with their "Bass Pro Shops" hat on, drinking beer while running their boat at 60 miles per hour and chucking empty beer cans into the water while ignoring laws on methods to catch fish (ie. barbless hooks)........and doing all of this without a license, because a license is "optional" right???
I respect if you don't like hunting but please don't make assumptions and generalize, as you are painting a picture out of ignorance.