Better plan not to fish here,

OldBlackDog

Well-Known Member
VICTORIA – The Ministry of Agriculture and Lands has issued one new finfish license, one replacement finfish license, and one new shellfish license, and denied another application for a shellfish license. These decisions are based on the biological suitability of the sites, the technical merits of the applications, and consultation with First Nations, communities and other government agencies.

A replacement finfish license was issued to Creative Salmon Company Ltd. to grow Chinook salmon at a marine water-based facility on the southwest corner of Warne Island at the entrance of Tofino Inlet. The site is a replacement for the Tranquil aquaculture license, which is being relocated due to poor tidal flushing and concerns by First Nations. Surrender of the Tranquil site is a condition of the tenure offer for Warne Island. The proposed site lies solely within the asserted traditional territory of the Tla-o-qui-aht First Nations, who provided letters of support for the application.

The second finfish license was issued to Grieg Seafood B.C. Ltd. to grow Atlantic salmon at a marine water-based facility in Nootka Sound on the north shore of Muchalat Inlet, just east of the juncture with Williamson Passage. It is the last of six sites discussed in a settlement agreement by the Province and the Mowachaht/Muchalaht First Nation. Provisions were made in the agreement for siting a total of six marine finfish farms in the settlement area, only four of which were to be operational at any one time to allow for fallowing and better site management. This site is located in an area designated as acceptable for aquaculture by the Nootka Sound Coastal Land Use Plan.

In another decision, an application by Island Scallops Ltd., to amend their existing license to include 125 hectares of sub-surface longlines for Japanese scallop culture, was approved. The site is located off the east side of Vancouver Island near Bowser. The license requires that all farm structures be a minimum of 1.1 km off-shore, with no surface structures other than buoys required to ensure safe navigation.
Finally, a submission by Discovery Diving Ltd., for a geoduck clam sub-tidal facility proposed off Wilson Creek on the Sunshine Coast, was denied. Amongst other factors, the site was rejected due to the sensitive habitat designation of the area.

Numerous parties were consulted on these applications, including the Canadian Coast Guard, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Ministry of Forests and Range, Ministry of Environment, Environment Canada, the First Nations groups in the area, non-governmental organizations, the Regional Districts and the public.

All decisions on aquaculture licences in British Columbia are based on the following principles: fairness; transparency; efficiency; accountability; protection of public health and safety; protection of the environment; and sustainable economic development.
 
I can hear Tom Bird and Brian Dane crying from my house!

Great news on the scallop tenure. Finally some cover for those Nile and Big Q fish. Hate to give them any sort of a break I guess...

Scallop farming and fish farming are in no way similar.

And for what it's worth, I am leaving Island Scallops to work in the sportfishing sector and I'll always support what they do and how they do it.
 
I think it was island Scallops that was denied an expansion of their scallops growing between Denman Island and Vanc. Island because of danger to boats, plus their inability to control their gear in storms, causing lots of mess on the shore of Denman.
Don
 
Oh the politics and wordsmithing of it all...

'Official' reasons for that tenure's denial I'm sure, real reasons - hmmmm. Estetics certainly seem be at the heart for many.

There has been a lease on the Denman site for 15 years - people hurt boating on said tenure - ??? (none)

The only gear lost is sometimes floats in nasty nasty weather. Definitely ends up on shorelines. Where it can be cleaned up. Much better than sinking to the bottom of the ocean - or wait, at least it's not visible then...

By the way, this company also hosts clean ups of different shorelines, where oyster junk, garbage from recreation and just general crap gets cleaned up. If you'd like to participate in one there is an opportunity to do so on April 5.
 
Hey Osama, what are you going to be doing...... SS
 
Does this mean no scallops for the Chum Derby Hopper?
 
just another big mutli national f**kin' up our coastline....what a joke....125 hectares plus closed to fishing, (size of Stanley Park)....and your in favour of this.....give your head a shake
 
Geez Osama

Am I the only one that knew about this before?

Good luck with the new endeavour and see you out Bamfield way.

I think there may be some scallops at the derby still.
 
First off, fishingBC - 'another big multi-national blah blah blah..."
- what a joke is right - ha ha - but it's you!!!

The owner/CEO lives in Qualicum. WOW.

Good job on the research. Top notch stuff there.

- Casper - Don't worry, Baddog is right. Will still be scallops. Island Scallops actually sponsors our little ****show out there, it's not just me scoopin' them.

- C.S. - Thank christ we have an official reason not to hang out anymore. For your information, I plan to earn my living in the 'Sportfishing Sector' simply by following your boat and collecting empies...

-S.S. - Will be guiding on the west coast.
 
Island Scallops is owned by Edgewater Foods....you don't even know who your former employer is....google it up stupid
 
A few???

Do you have any concept of how many people this company employs???

C.A. I would love to actually give you a tour of the facility and introduce you to the owner.

And yes, the company is registered in Nevada, but perhaps that has something to do with financing...

Robert Saunders. CEO. Started the company. Still owns the majority of the shares. Lives in Qualicum Beach and works every single day with the rest of his forty someodd employees.
 
wintertripjeffandfish.jpg
spend a few days looking into what you THINK you know and come back and post....

And yes, the company is registered in Nevada, but perhaps that has something to do with financing


Edgewater owns Island Scallops.....tour been there done that.....they have no money.....its all being raised on stock market...Saunders...he's a joke too....his wife works at DFO in aquaculture research....theres no conflict of interest there....droppin Tom and Brian names....nice touch....
 
Your point fishingbc???

Tom and Brians names - they have dropped them in every article they could garnish interest in.

Again. The companies CEO and founder lives in Qualicum Beach and works every day.

You go so some research and then come bach and post...

Calling Saunders a joke - nice touch...

Figure it out.
 
Somebody needs to go out and kill a fish, too much tension on here as of late. Sorry I'm stuck working. We need a good fishing story ....
 
been a long three year fight by
BC Wildlife Federation
Sport Fish Advisory Board
Campbell River and District Fishing Guides Association
Sport Fishing Institute of BC
Trout Unlimited Canada
Georgia Strait Aliance
Fishing Vessel Owners Association
Herring Research and Conservation Society
Vancouver Island Saltwater Guides Association
Herring Industry Advisory Board
Underwater Harvesters Association
BC Nature (Federation of British Columbia Naturalists)
Nature Canada 30,000 members
Courtenay Fish and Game
Shady Shores Resort
Life is a Beach B&B
Deep Bay RV Park
Commercial Herring Boat owners
Members of Ducks Unlimited
Nile Creek Enhancement Society
hundreds of residents in the immediate area
on and on and on
to stop this ridiculous aquaculture mega project....ya I'm pissed as are thousands who took the time send their comments into Transport Canada (the agency doing the review)Our governments are too focused on promoting aquaculture and not on what should be there focus, our native resources.....Since most have no idea....I will post more info so you all can see what is up with this stupid decision...small valley??????????????



quote:Originally posted by C.S.

Hey Gil...your getting a little personal there.

Its a small island and even a smaller valley!
 
THE COMPANY

· Edgewater Foods International Inc., ("the Company" and/or "Edgewater Foods") is a Nevada Corporation and the parent company of Island Scallops Ltd. ("ISL"), a Vancouver Island aquaculture company.

· Island Scallops Ltd. (ISL) was established in 1989 to commercialize Canadian government research on scallop aquaculture.

THE PRODUCT

· ISL has developed a hybrid species of scallop known as the “Pacific Scallop”. This new species was derived from the local Weathervane Scallop and the Japanese Scallop and is much larger than either parent. It is considered an “exotic species” and cannot be grown in US waters.

· ISL projects 100 million scallops could be produced (Edgewater Foods press release October 18, 2006) from the lease area.

ISL plans to grow Pacific Scallops suspended from a massive array of underwater ropes and floats anchored in their existing lease in front of the community of Bowser.

· The original lease was established for bottom culture only and measures approximately 3.5 km in length and 1 km in width covering an area of 375 ha (926 acres) almost as large as Stanley Park.

· The current proposal measures 2.5 km in length and 0.5 km in width covering an area of 125 ha (309 acres) within the existing lease. ISL has stated that the project could expand further into the lease area if successful.

· This proposal is the largest single aquaculture (finfish and shellfish) project ever conceived in British Columbia. The proposal is considered simply a change in management plan as the original lease was established much earlier.

· The existing lease area represents 70% of the total shellfish tenures and a six-fold increase (600%) over the entire off-bottom shellfish culture in Baynes Sound (based on information reported in 2002).

· Baynes Sound produced 3,360 tonnes of shellfish in 2001. This represents 50% of total cultured shellfish farmed in B.C. The forecasted scallop production from the Bowser farm of up to 5,000 tonnes annually is greater than the entire amount of all shellfish produced in Baynes Sound and will be concentrated in a comparatively smaller area.

A massive underwater array of ropes and suspended strings of scallops will be anchored throughout the proposed area in a series of 83 rows occupying the full 500 m width.

· The structures will involve 67% of the area’s cross-section.

· Approximately 25,000 m (25 km) of 1” polypropylene rope will be used for mainline and 30,000m (30 km) of 1” polypropylene rope will be used for anchorline.

· Approximately 500 anchors will be used to moor the structures.

· Approximately 2000 floats will be used on the longlines to lift the structure above the bottom of the ocean.

ON THE SURFACE

· More than 60 navigation floats will be used (NWPA requirement) around the perimeter of the proposed area.

· The farm will employ 4 to 5 large workboats (40’) at the site 7 days per week during the period from May to November. The work frequency will be reduced by half during the other months of the year.

THE RESOURCE

· The lease area is in the middle of one of the most valuable herring staging and spawning areas in the entire Gulf of Georgia.

· The area is used extensively by juvenile salmon and herring as a feeding and nursery area.

· The 2004 Wholesale value of the herring fishery in BC was $83.5 million, more than 3 times the value of farmed shellfish.

· The area is a critical staging, breeding and wintering area for migratory birds and considered the most important waterfowl habitat in British Columbia after the Fraser River estuary.

· Over a typical year, more than 176 bird species use the area. Of these, 20 species are on the British Columbia Conservation Data Centre list as being species of concern (Blue listed), while 4 are considered threatened (Red listed) (Source: Canadian Wildlife Service). Globally significant populations of nine species of birds including trumpeter swans, great blue herons and Pacific loons use the area.

· The area is in the middle of a Chinook salmon conservation area as established by DFO for protection of specific at-risk stocks.

· A variety of marine mammals including seals, sea lions and otters travel through and feed in the area.

· Recreational fishers including fishing guides who normally fish by trolling lures using downriggers, fish the area extensively.

THE RISK

· This section of Georgia Strait is fully exposed to extreme wave conditions caused by prevailing southeast storms and many kilometres of fetch.

· Failure of anchors or tensioning could result in sudden surfacing of floats and longlines creating a hazard to navigation.

· Anchor or tensioning failure during storm conditions could cause lines to drift into others causing a chain reaction that could result in catastrophic collapse of the facility.

· Mooring clusters of floats on the surface for long periods of time in the farm area is common practice at existing facilities of this type and create a hazard to vessel navigation.

THE IMPACTS

· The valuable herring fishery will be eliminated in the vicinity of the lease due to interference with the underwater scallop structures. Fishing vessels must maintain a large buffer zone around the farm area to avoid fouling nets and anchors in the farm structures.

· Recreational fishing will be eliminated in the vicinity of the lease due to interference with the underwater farm structures.

· Juvenile salmon and herring feed on the same food source as scallops and their massive numbers (100 million) could limit the food supply for these important fish species resulting in population decline.

· Tens of millions of pounds of waste products produced annually by 100 million scallops and by cleaning fouling organisms from lines and floats could overwhelm the local environment and add to the cumulative effects of raft culture in Baynes Sound.

· Constant activity at the site will displace important bird species and prevent them from gathering and feeding.

· Failure of the farm structures could result in a massive debris source that could foul beaches and present a major hazard to navigation.

· A major industrial operation located within visual and audio range of the Bowser community will be a constant annoyance to residents and visitors alike and could reduce tourism and property values.

STUDIES

· No scientific or socio-economic studies have been carried out in the ISL lease area. Studies specific to Baynes Sound are not transferable to the proposed lease area in the Gulf of Georgia.

· The only published assessment of the lease area was carried out in 1999 by Axys Environmental Consulting Ltd. and concluded that the area was not suitable for off-bottom shellfish culture.

· The proposal is undergoing a “screening” review by Transport Canada under the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act. The Act does not consider direct socio-economic impacts such as elimination of commercial and recreational fishing or losses to community, tourism or property values as valid concerns and such issues are not included in any review or decision.

CONCLUSIONS

· The proposed scallop farm will have significant detrimental impact upon biological, environmental, and commercial resources and upon community socio-economics.

· The Canadian Environmental Assessment Act does not address direct socio-economic impacts and is of no value to protection of existing public resources or community assets.

· Specific scientific, biological and socio-economic studies must be undertaken to evaluate the impact of the development.
 
Look on the bright side:


THE IMPACTS

· The valuable herring fishery will be eliminated in the vicinity of the lease due to interference with the underwater scallop structures. Fishing vessels must maintain a large buffer zone around the farm area to avoid fouling nets and anchors in the farm structures.[:0]
 
Hey Osama,
Good luck with the new job!
I sure hope we will see you at the chum derby in the fall..
If you and the wife are going out fishing kitty drop me a line..will meet you out there..OH..we got out limits too today prawns..think of you every time we drive by the farm..
 
Back
Top