I’m with you as well. I would be somewhat disappointed if someone bonked a fish like that but I wouldn’t crucify them that’s for sure. It’s in their right and who knows really, if a guy caught one and it was damaged bad in the gills then why not. Personally I’ve struggled with this issue over the years and always said I would keep one but I have changed my view on it. I think mid to high 40’s would be my limit to keep a big one, anything over that would go back in. But I know one thing I would be very cautious and probably not share it on social media if I did, especially not on here, way to many holier than thou spectators. Which is sad considering this is fishing forum and we should be encouraging all forms of legal participation.