Oceans for Farming not Hunting.

Barbender

Active Member
This was in the Province. Just a different spin to drive AA and LH nuts. Read on and let the fireworks begin. Just to be safe I will be wearing head gear...jab, jab, right cross, upercut!

It's time we used the oceans for farming rather than for hunting
Ruth Salmon, The Province
Published: Wednesday, October 08, 2008
There's been a lot of attention given to the regulation -- and overall sustainability -- of the salmon farming industry in BC and across the country.

Here are the facts: The Canadian aquaculture industry is governed by a framework of 73 pieces of federal and provincial legislation, making it one of the most strictly regulated industries in the world.

Both the location and day-to-day operations of all Canadian aquaculture facilities are regulated by five federal agencies: Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Environment Canada, Canadian Food Inspection Agency, Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, and Health Canada.


Email to a friend

Printer friendly
Font:****All proposed aquaculture developments are subject to an environmental review, which includes the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act.

Farms can only be sited in areas where water currents provide optimal conditions for fish health and environmental sustainability.

Environmental monitoring involves computer modeling, water-quality sensors, satellite imaging and Geographical Information System technology, coupled with sea-floor sampling and video recording.

Aquaculture sites must also adhere to an array of provincial statutes, regulations, policies and guidelines. Farms must often comply with municipal, Regional District, and First Nations' land use and development regulatory instruments.

The B.C. Ministry of Agriculture and Lands 2007 Fish Health Report shows salmon farmers maintain high fish health management standards. The provincial fish health management program includes on-site health management plans, mandatory monitoring, disease reporting and an audit of industry information.

On the west coast, activists allege sea lice from salmon farms are killing wild pink salmon in the Broughton.

Did you know the largest return of pink salmon every recorded in that area was in 2001 -- more than a decade after the start of salmon farming in the Broughton? Let's look at the big picture. Without aquaculture, the United Nations forecasts a global seafood shortage of 50 to 80 million tonnes by 2030.

Aquaculture must play a key role in the supply of healthy proteins for a growing global population.

New studies in Norway found salmon farming can be a net fish protein producer. Results show that 1.2 kg of fish protein was produced for each kilogram of fish protein used in the feed. This came by substituting vegetable proteins, and the level of Omega-3 fatty acids in the salmon was not reduced.

Canada's aquaculture industry, which generates more than $969 million annually and employs 16,000 people, grows a lot more than salmon. Our industry offers more than a dozen types of fresh seafood -- everything from oysters to rainbow trout -- year 'round.

As Jacques Cousteau said, it's time we used the sea as farmers, instead of hunters.
 
Interesting point of view that has some merit. However, I think the better approach is to do both hunting and farming (as long as the farming is in closed containment systems). In regards to the issue of monitoring and enforcement of standards, etc...

"The B.C. Ministry of Agriculture and Lands 2007 Fish Health Report shows salmon farmers maintain high fish health management standards. The provincial fish health management program includes on-site health management plans, mandatory monitoring, disease reporting and an audit of industry information."

I have very reliable information that the compliance and enforcement monitoring does not happen as much as it needs to do to lack of qualified staff and resources. If you doubt it ask the Ministry staff involved and if they are brave enough, they will tell you reality of the matter. If we don't like this situation then we need to tell our politicians to make it more of a priority in the upcoming election. That's my 2 bits.

Sharp hooks and full traps!
 
Barbender, you forgot to include who wrote the article.

Ruth Salmon, executive director of the Canadian Aquaculture Industry Alliance.
 
I wouldn't excpect someone like her to tell us fish farming is bad.

Take only what you need.
 
So FA, Ruth is bad and can't be trusted because she speaks positively on salmon farms. And people who are against salmon farms are good, and would never bend the truth, right?

Nope no double standard here

Closed containment for salmon makes about as much sense as growing dairy cows in bubbles under the water.

I still have yet to hear one of you explain how the salmon runs were highest in the Broughton during the years when farnms were present than at any other time?
 
This op/ed followed shortly after Ruth Salmon's. Always good to hear from both sides.
http://www.canada.com/theprovince/news/editorial/story.html?id=c053c532-ca6c-4c93-a531-722e53bb32aa
This kinda backs up what whole-in-the-water wrote.

B.C.'s salmon farmers given a free ride by our provincial 'regulators'
Catherine Stewart, Special to The Province
Published: Friday, October 10, 2008

In a recent opinion piece defending salmon farming, Ruth Salmon of the Canadian Aquaculture Industry Association rightly stated that the B.C. fish farming industry faces a plethora of regulations and requirements.

We have speeding laws too, but imagine if our traffic laws were enforced the same way that salmon farmers are regulated.Every driver would voluntarily report their violations to the police: "Dear Officer, yesterday I went 60 past an elementary school. Please send the ticket to . . ."

Regulations are meaningless if they are not enforced. By and large, the salmon farming industry in B.C. reports to its association who provide cumulative data to governments. Data such as the number of escaped Atlantic salmon, how many sea lions were shot or drowned in net cages or the regional total of antibiotics pumped into the fish.

When the industry data does arrive in provincial offices the bureaucrats don't question the numbers.

One example is that salmon farms are required to report their usage of SliceTM, a neurotoxic pesticide added to feed to treat the constant sea lice outbreaks on the farms. Living Oceans Society recently asked the B.C.

Ministry of Environment for the amount of Slice used in 2007 by the three big Norwegian aquaculture corporations that own 92 per cent of B.C.'s salmon farms.

The list was short and according to the province's spreadsheet, one company, Mainstream, used 562,732 kilograms on just eight farms -- an unbelievably high amount.

We contacted the company who resolved the error and provided the correct figures. But the stated use of over half a million kilos of this chemical should have set off alarm bells in an agency charged with enforcing regulations.

It didn't.

And it gets worse.

Oslo-based Marine Harvest, the world's largest salmon farmer, is the only company to voluntarily post the dates of Slice treatments on its Canadian web site.

The list provided by the province named seven MH farms that used Slice in 2007. A quick scan of the company's web site showed Slice treatments at an additional six B.C. farm sites that year.

In a follow-up phone call, Marine Harvest confirmed an additional eight sites had used Slice in 2007.

We asked, but our government clearly isn't asking. It just accepts the voluntary company reports and then publishes regular reports proclaiming overwhelming compliance with "the toughest regulations in the world."

Slice is just the iceberg tip of regulatory failure in B.C.

Returns of wild salmon to the Broughton Archipelago are at an all-time low and grizzly bears in the Glendale River are starving.

Clam beaches down-current from farms are covered in rotting black sludge.

Rockfish near salmon farms have higher levels of mercury contamination. Sea lions and seals are drowned and shot and medicated feed and feces smother the ocean floor beneath the farms.

Ms. Salmon, the fish farming industry and our "regulators" keep repeating the refrain, "all is well." It isn't.

Our governments are failing to protect our salmon, our oceans and our future from open net-cage salmon farms. That is a fact.

Catherine Stewart represents the Living Oceans Society


© The Vancouver Province 2008
 
Gotta love it. Another balanced well informed insight into the positive aspects of fish farming by an impartial author. Time to rake some leaves......
 
quote:So FA, Ruth is bad and can't be trusted because she speaks positively on salmon farms. And people who are against salmon farms are good, and would never bend the truth, right?

Sockeye fry if this is what You think of her just come out and say it, don't try to put words into my mouth.. [B)]

All I said is you can't expect someone who is employed by farming salmon to shoot herself in the foot and shed any negatives on the industry. She wants to paint a bright picture. I bet you won't hear her telling everyone that the worst case scenario is the complete extinction of wild salmon on the coast.

She has a cool last name though, I wonder if she changed it to that?

Take only what you need.
 
quote:We contacted the company who resolved the error and provided the correct figures.

The correct amount was 3kg. Wonder why they never said in the article? The fact that sea lice are at a all time low and that virtually no treatment is needed. I guess that was not the point really, how can you scare people if they know the truth.
 
Back
Top