Lots of comments at salmon meetings

Sushihunter

Active Member
http://www.qciobserver.com/Article.aspx?Id=3556

Lots of comments at salmon meetings

By Margo Hearne--It didn't take long for the public to express their thoughts about what'shappening to wild salmon in our communities.

Public meetings held by the Pacific Fisheries Resource Conservation Council (PFRCC) in Masset Nov. 4 and Skidegate Nov. 5 brought out strong opinions, beginning with an introduction by Reynold Russ, Chief Iljuuwaas, in Masset.

"It's wonderful to see you here," Chief Iljuuwaas said by way of introduction, "but it's a little late. I see there's nothing on the information board about the sport fishing industry and we have to deal with that. Fishing was my life and always has been; there were about 60 trollers and about 25 seine boats working out of here and there were times when I couldn't get a deckhand because everyone was fishing. Nobody is now fishing. I retired in 1990 and it's hard to believe what's happening. People from San Francisco and from across Canada come here to fish and aboriginal people have been phased out again."

Gordon Ennis, from the PFRCC, explained their main agenda was to hear from the communities. "We're a Minister's Advisory Council," he said. "We have some influence and report directly to the Minister.

Our mandate is wild salmon - we're here to look at strategic issues and concerns re their long term survival. We're concerned with climate change and looking at eco-system based management. We've visited sixteen communities so far. Our reports are delivered to both Federal and Provincial Governments. We want the Minister to stand up and defend wild salmon."

Many members of the public noted that they were commercial fishermen, now they sit on shore and watch the sport lodges come in and take the salmon.

"The 'sporties' didn't have a good year this year and they're crying "where are the salmon?" said Robin Brown of Old Massett and a fisherman for 50 years. "We didn't take them; the aboriginal people can't fish. There is absolutely no control of the sport fishery."

"Salmon are not treated well by the sport fishermen," said one person. "I've watched them come in, and the salmon are like rags, slopping around in a slurry at the bottom of the boat. Coho have such strong stomach acid that they have to be cleaned almost immediately or they get 'belly burn'. There is no training on how to deal with these fish, there's no respect for them."

"The 'catch and release' program should be banned outright," said one. "Once a salmon is caught and begins to bleed, it's game over. Yet, they are often released because they're too small and not a 'trophy'. The Haida Nation want priority for this resource and each fish that's taken or injured is one less fish for us. It's a valuable food, not sport. I do a boat count at the lodges and with over 80 boats catching and releasing, that's a lot of dead fish. They are annihilating our species one by one. When they can't get salmon, they go after halibut."

The destruction of creeks in the Queen Charlotte lowlands by beavers was discussed. "The Chown Brook is almost completely choked by beaver dams," said one. "There is no way returning salmon can go up there."

Habitat destruction by logging; over-fishing; warmer water from climate change and lack of funding for stock assessment were just some of the other concerns, but the bottom line was wild salmon are disappearing. As one person noted, "anyone who allows draggers to scrape the bottom shouldn't be allowed to manage fish; DFO shouldn't be allowed to manage these fish."



Jim's Fishing Charters
www.JimsFishing.com
http://ca.youtube.com/user/Sushihunter250
 
Can't believe the commercials are still spouting the same old tired bullcrap about how the spotfishing lodges are the cause of the demise of the salmon stocks around the Charlottes.
I've posted this before but it seems appropriate here so here's how it was.
In 1990 the Haida were involved in blockading the Charlotte Princess at Langara claiming that the sporties were killing too many fish and that they had to pay a "fee" to the Haida to operate there as well.
Bob Wright refused to pay them off so they blockaded his ship/lodge.
So, in the interest of seeing just how many salmon were being taken around Langara and by whom, I gathered the following information.
At the time of the blockade, June of 1990, the total number of Chinook salmon killed by the lodges was about 3500. Obviously the season would last a couple more months so that number would increase, but for this comparison that's what it was.
In a nine day troller opening held just after the blockade, the commercial sector landed 65,000 pieces (Chinook mostly).
So, on the one hand we have 3500 dead salmon taken over roughly a two month period and on the other we have 65,000 dead salmon taken in nine days by commercial trollers.
And yet they have the audacity to claim that the sporties "killed all our fish."
The facts show otherwise.

I was there and I went to the meetings and I listened to all the crap from both sides.
There are several things that have adversely affected our salmon resources the past 100 years or so, but the take by sporties ranks way down the list compared to many of the other reasons.

"Nuff said.


Take care.
 
quote:Originally posted by Dave H

Can't believe the commercials are still spouting the same old tired bullcrap about how the spotfishing lodges are the cause of the demise of the salmon stocks around the Charlottes.
They are ignorant small minded people who are overwhelmed by the real world, they thought their gravy train of government subsidised living would last forever.
quote:Originally posted by Dave H.....In 1990 the Haida were involved in blockading the Charlotte Princess at Langara claiming that the sporties were killing too many fish and that they had to pay a "fee" to the Haida to operate there as well.
Bob Wright refused to pay them off so they blockaded his ship/lodge.
I was on the Charlotte Princess the day they started that crap!
quote:Originally posted by Dave HThere are several things that have adversely affected our salmon resources the past 100 years or so, but the take by sporties ranks way down the list compared to many of the other reasons.
Again quite true!
It's interesting to see that the changes brought about by Michael Coe of Westcoast Sportfishing haven't been the whole answer.He made sure to 'pay court' to native interests and alway hire some locals to work in the Lodges so do others including Queen Charlotte Lodge and Langara Fishing Lodge.
In a small place like QCI there's always some jealous whiner I've seen it in many places, not the best side of human nature that's for sure.[V]



kidphotors6.jpg
 
Back
Top