Kenny don't twist my words. Have zero issues with guides. Use guides throughout the year. Friends with many guides.
My issue is on a river like the squamish....you have a couple tackle stores who offer walk and wades raft trips etc. The anglers take in the knowledge and how-to get to certain areas. In 10 years we have gone from a couple rafts and maybe a handful of anglers each day to close to a dozen rafts and 40 to 50 plus anglers a day in the spring. The fish get absolutely beat on...
Playing the same fish over and over again. Seeing dead steelhead and dollies in the shallows is not an uncommon experience now.
The numbers of fish don't justify the amount of pressure they recieve.
We couldn't guide on the Thompson why is it ok on an even smaller system?