I fish both extensively. My preference is the lighter version. Excellent rod, no issues. I have a lot of clients on the boat, and they aren't always kind to the rods and they stand up. Yes, I have broken 2 in the past 4 seasons. Both were brand new and failed on the first trip out so there was clearly something wrong. The other 6 rods I have been fishing are so far bullet proof. BTW, I also fished 2 technium's and have broken both. Fortunately both were warranted. So I still have 2 that I use but would say on balance they don't seem to be standing up nearly as well as the Classic Moocher. I have yet to find a rod that is truly bullet proof - they all have their issues. However for the money I really am hooked on the classic moocher in the lighter action. Hope that helps.