Minister isn't doing enough, quickly enough, to protect Chinook salmon

Well I didn’t mind any part of this and on top of all of it, it’s in big time newspaper. That folks is a shot across the bow. That’s a completely political oped without any political overtures! It’s saying very politely to Ottawa to pull your heads out of your asses, science should have kept much of the rec Chinook fishery open to certainly Johnson and Georgia water if not more. Science is what this Government ran on, is running this time on, but threw science out the window when setting their Chinook Policy. Hmmm, that’s double talk boys or as we like to call it out west, it’s &)~<%# lyin
Great folks beat them at their own game
 
https://vancouversun.com/news/natio...alth/wcm/a89f3bc7-aedb-4b3b-8bd6-ee7d0bcb6d48

Regardless of all the political or FN netting issues, this is why conservation right now is so critical. I for one am glad to give up fishing to protect them.

The current closure is to protect upper Fraser river chinook stocks,

The SRKW restrictions are separate from that.

I think your mixing up a few issues here the northern straight of Georgia and Johnson straight is closed right now and that closure has nothing todo with SRKW. In fact the NRKW are thriving in that location.
 
Last edited:
The current closure is to protect upper Fraser river chinook stocks,

The SRKW restrictions are separate from that.

I think your mixing up a few issues here the northern straight of Georgia and Johnson straight is closed right now and that closure has nothing todo with SRKW. In fact the NRKW are thriving in that location.

You can see these posts coming a mile away.:rolleyes: I wouldn't worry about it.
 
The article is completely BS as they are comparing it to when she was pregnant a few years ago!!!! It was on chek as well with pictures. Do some research
Bang on...J-53 (calf from J-17) was first spotted Oct 24, 2015. The comparative photo analysis is very misleading. They need to get their facts straight. They also need to do some more research to back up claims that its food abundance that is the cause of nutritional distress. There is a very real possibility that its related to physical and acoustic disturbances combined with long-term exposure to toxins. Some of these scientists may be mistakenly making assumptions about the cause, and therefore diagnosing the wrong prescription for the cure.

You never hear them closely examining the number of Chinook available in the environment and calculating the caloric intake requirements necessary to support SRKW. We need science not supposition. Based on what I can determine from the Chinook indicator stocks that we have a forecast for 2019, there will be 571,000 returning Fraser and Puget fish alone. The caloric intake requirements based on studies I have been able to find assess the needs to be around 142,000 fish or 25% of what is available. The real question is what is the actual goal here? How many Chinook do we need to have available to support SRKW? A NOAA study stated there were 9 - 22 time the Chinook available to meet caloric requirements from just the Puget Chinook alone. So what is the real problem here, and again what is the food availability goal?

All we get is we need more chinook - how many more? All we get is lets close fisheries - that will solve the problem...how foolish...do the math, the number of Chinook of specific stocks that SRKW actually target which are caught within the rec fishery is very low. What's the number of Fraser Chinook removed from recreational fishing? Is that actually enough to make any real difference?

We need goals not supposition.
 
The article is completely BS as they are comparing it to when she was pregnant a few years ago!!!! It was on chek as well with pictures. Do some research
Nonsense. Perhaps it's you that should do some research.

https://www.westcoast.fisheries.noaa.gov/stories/2019/15_05152019-srkw-j17.html

Aerial images document Southern Resident killer whale J17’s continued decline

May 2019

Continued research on endangered Southern Resident killer whales has become critical for understanding the health of individual whales and the population. Scientists from NOAA Fisheries’ Southwest Fisheries Science Center and SR3: Sealife Response, Rehabilitation, and Research have collected high-resolution aerial images of Southern Residents since 2008, documenting changes in their body condition.

j17_aerial_sr3_noaa_nmfs_research_permit_19091.jpg


Aerial images of adult female Southern Resident killer whale “J17," displaying very poor body condition on May 6th 2019. Note the white eye patches that trace the outline of her skull due to a reduction in fat around the head. Her condition is contrasted to September 2018, when she was also very lean but had not yet developed such an obvious "peanut head", and to September 2015 when she was clearly pregnant (note width at mid body) and in peak recent condition. Images obtained by Holly Fearnbach (SR3) and John Durban (NOAA Fisheries’ Southwest Fisheries Science Center) using a remotely-piloted drone under NMFS Research Permit #19091.

This spring the collaborative team used a drone, flown under permit at more than 100 feet above the whales, to collect new aerial images of Southern Resident killer whales in J-pod. These images showed that J17, an adult female that had deteriorated in body condition in recent years, has further declined since she was assessed last fall. J17’s three-and-a-half-year-old daughter, J53, has also declined in condition.

These scientists noted in images released last year that J17’s condition had deteriorated since giving birth to J53 in fall 2015. The new images collected last week show that J17 is now demonstrating the condition known as “peanut-head,” which indicates a significant loss of fat (or blubber) around the head. NOAA Fisheries and SR3 will continue to monitor J17 and J53’s condition, as well as all other individuals, throughout this summer.

The Northwest Fisheries Science Center will add to the aerial visual health assessments by collecting feces, breath and scraps of the whales’ prey when possible. Such samples provide information on the whales’ diet, potential pregnancies, and exposure to pathogens. Researchers believe that a variety of factors, including malnutrition, disease, and disturbance are impacting the population’s recovery.

J17 and J53 were last observed together and in the same area as other whales from J pod. NOAA Fisheries does not plan to intervene with J17 or J53 at this time but will continue to work with partners to gather additional information, evaluate options and consult with experts.

The public can help Southern Resident killer whales by giving them space to forage undisturbed and respecting the mandated state and federal viewing distances. NOAA Fisheries is also working with researchers to closely coordinate and limit their approaches around these whales.



Soundwatch vessel displays the warning flag that indicates whales are in the area. The flag is a signal to slow down, watch for the whales, keep your distance and stay out of their path. Photo: Frances Robertson, San Juan County Marine Resources Committee

Washington Governor Jay Inslee last week signed a state law requiring all vessels to stay at least 300 yards from Southern Resident killer whales. The state law also requires vessels to stay at least 400 yards out of the path of or behind the whales, and slow to less than 7 knots within a half-mile of the whales. For reference on the water, 300 yards is about the length of three Washington state ferries. Canada also announced a new approach distance of 400 meters (~437 yards) for killer whales, which will go into effect in June in Canadian waters.
whale-warning-flag.jpg


Whale warning flag. Courtesy San Juan County Marine Resources Committee. See the MRC’s webpage for further information about the flags, including how to obtain them.

Whale warning flags flown by any vessel indicate that whales are in the area. The flag is a signal to slow below 7 knots, and watch for the whales, while keeping your distance and staying out of their path. BeWhaleWise.org has been updated with the latest state laws and federal regulations, and provides a ready reference for boaters.

For more on how you can help Southern Residents, visit:

https://www.westcoast.fisheries.noaa.gov/protected_species/marine_mammals/killer_whale/
 
Have to disagree on this one Gil. Maybe you should do more research as well.:rolleyes:

Nonsense. Perhaps it's you that should do some research.

https://www.westcoast.fisheries.noaa.gov/stories/2019/15_05152019-srkw-j17.html

Aerial images document Southern Resident killer whale J17’s continued decline

May 2019

Continued research on endangered Southern Resident killer whales has become critical for understanding the health of individual whales and the population. Scientists from NOAA Fisheries’ Southwest Fisheries Science Center and SR3: Sealife Response, Rehabilitation, and Research have collected high-resolution aerial images of Southern Residents since 2008, documenting changes in their body condition.

j17_aerial_sr3_noaa_nmfs_research_permit_19091.jpg


Aerial images of adult female Southern Resident killer whale “J17," displaying very poor body condition on May 6th 2019. Note the white eye patches that trace the outline of her skull due to a reduction in fat around the head. Her condition is contrasted to September 2018, when she was also very lean but had not yet developed such an obvious "peanut head", and to September 2015 when she was clearly pregnant (note width at mid body) and in peak recent condition. Images obtained by Holly Fearnbach (SR3) and John Durban (NOAA Fisheries’ Southwest Fisheries Science Center) using a remotely-piloted drone under NMFS Research Permit #19091.

This spring the collaborative team used a drone, flown under permit at more than 100 feet above the whales, to collect new aerial images of Southern Resident killer whales in J-pod. These images showed that J17, an adult female that had deteriorated in body condition in recent years, has further declined since she was assessed last fall. J17’s three-and-a-half-year-old daughter, J53, has also declined in condition.

These scientists noted in images released last year that J17’s condition had deteriorated since giving birth to J53 in fall 2015. The new images collected last week show that J17 is now demonstrating the condition known as “peanut-head,” which indicates a significant loss of fat (or blubber) around the head. NOAA Fisheries and SR3 will continue to monitor J17 and J53’s condition, as well as all other individuals, throughout this summer.

The Northwest Fisheries Science Center will add to the aerial visual health assessments by collecting feces, breath and scraps of the whales’ prey when possible. Such samples provide information on the whales’ diet, potential pregnancies, and exposure to pathogens. Researchers believe that a variety of factors, including malnutrition, disease, and disturbance are impacting the population’s recovery.

J17 and J53 were last observed together and in the same area as other whales from J pod. NOAA Fisheries does not plan to intervene with J17 or J53 at this time but will continue to work with partners to gather additional information, evaluate options and consult with experts.

The public can help Southern Resident killer whales by giving them space to forage undisturbed and respecting the mandated state and federal viewing distances. NOAA Fisheries is also working with researchers to closely coordinate and limit their approaches around these whales.



Soundwatch vessel displays the warning flag that indicates whales are in the area. The flag is a signal to slow down, watch for the whales, keep your distance and stay out of their path. Photo: Frances Robertson, San Juan County Marine Resources Committee

Washington Governor Jay Inslee last week signed a state law requiring all vessels to stay at least 300 yards from Southern Resident killer whales. The state law also requires vessels to stay at least 400 yards out of the path of or behind the whales, and slow to less than 7 knots within a half-mile of the whales. For reference on the water, 300 yards is about the length of three Washington state ferries. Canada also announced a new approach distance of 400 meters (~437 yards) for killer whales, which will go into effect in June in Canadian waters.
whale-warning-flag.jpg


Whale warning flag. Courtesy San Juan County Marine Resources Committee. See the MRC’s webpage for further information about the flags, including how to obtain them.

Whale warning flags flown by any vessel indicate that whales are in the area. The flag is a signal to slow below 7 knots, and watch for the whales, while keeping your distance and staying out of their path. BeWhaleWise.org has been updated with the latest state laws and federal regulations, and provides a ready reference for boaters.

For more on how you can help Southern Residents, visit:

https://www.westcoast.fisheries.noaa.gov/protected_species/marine_mammals/killer_whale/
 
I guess we will have to weight to september before we get an accurate comparison comparison september to may, is a bit disingenuous. Regardless saving the whales will fill the coffers of ENGO for years to come.


Calls to ban BC fishing of Chinook to save orcas

Alarming photos of a female J17 orca has the environmental community saying enough is enough. The southern resident killer whale population is at a 35-year-low. New aerial images are inspiring a call-to-action for a fishing ban on the whale’s principal source of food. Ashley Burr has the details.

https://www.citynews1130.com/video/2019/05/19/calls-to-ban-b-c-fishing-of-chinook-to-save-orcas/
 
I guess we will have to weight to september before we get an accurate comparison comparison september to may, is a bit disingenuous. Regardless saving the whales will fill the coffers of ENGO for years to come.


Calls to ban BC fishing of Chinook to save orcas

Alarming photos of a female J17 orca has the environmental community saying enough is enough. The southern resident killer whale population is at a 35-year-low. New aerial images are inspiring a call-to-action for a fishing ban on the whale’s principal source of food. Ashley Burr has the details.

https://www.citynews1130.com/video/2019/05/19/calls-to-ban-b-c-fishing-of-chinook-to-save-orcas/

J17 is pregnant in the first picture. She gave birth to J53 in October 2015.

http://www.orcanetwork.org/Main/index.php?categories_file=Births and Deaths

Totally misleading and solely intended to pull at the heart (and purse) strings of the unwashed masses.

Here is the picture and quote from the Chek news story:

ABEE218E-5996-46EE-AF24-1EAD5B782FAC.png
 
Back
Top