Goldfish Infestation in Dragon Lake.

Rotenone is a natural plant toxin used for centuries by indigenous peoples of
Southeast Asia and South America for the harvesting of fish for human con-
sumption. It has been used as a commercial insecticide for more than 150 years and
for the management of fish populations since the 1930s. Fisheries management
uses include eradication of pest fishes, quantifying populations, food web manipu-
lation, controlling fish diseases, and restoring water bodies for threatened species.
Rotenone is considered one of the most environmentally benign toxicants available
for fisheries management. Fish are acutely sensitive to rotenone poisoning, quickly
absorbing the toxin across the gill surface and dying within hours at concentrations
below 1 ppm, although individual species sensitivities vary widely. Aquatic inverte-
brates are generally less sensitive than fish, but it will cause significant collateral
loss of invertebrate fauna, although invertebrate populations quickly recover.
Humans and wildlife are comparatively insensitive to rotenone, which provides a
large safety margin between concentrations required to kill fish and those that may
prove harmful to non-target, non-aquatic organisms. Rotenone can be applied to
standing or flowing waters as a generally dispersed toxicant, either in liquid or
powdered form, or as formulated baits to target nuisance species. Rotenone is
chemically unstable and breaks down rapidly in the environment, yielding water-
soluble non-toxic products. It is readily metabolised to non-toxic excretable
substances in the bodies of vertebrates receiving a sub-lethal dose. Rotenone is not
considered to be carcinogenic. Recent experimental findings linking it to
Parkinsonian effects seem unlikely to occur under normal uses. Cost and availability
limit the use of rotenone to relatively small water bodies.

Rotenone is non-persistent in the environment, being
quickly broken down by light and heat. It does not accumulate in animals and is
readily metabolised and excreted.

Recent research interest in rotenone stems mainly from
biochemical interest in its highly specific action in selectively inhibiting
mitochondrial activity and its possible anticancer properties.


Read the full text, and judge it's dangers for yourself. It is not the same as agricultural workers being exposed regularly for years (as with unprotected pesticide use).

http://www.doc.govt.nz/documents/science-and-technical/SFC211.pdf




Saw a video of a rotenone application at a lake, and the persons were wearing those full haz mat suits, it may not be so safe after all.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/parkinsons-disease-and-pesticides-whats-the-connection/
https://www.nih.gov/news-events/new...-two-pesticides-associated-parkinsons-disease
 
Rotenone is a natural plant toxin used for centuries by indigenous peoples of
Southeast Asia and South America for the harvesting of fish for human con-
sumption. It has been used as a commercial insecticide for more than 150 years and
for the management of fish populations since the 1930s. Fisheries management
uses include eradication of pest fishes, quantifying populations, food web manipu-
lation, controlling fish diseases, and restoring water bodies for threatened species.
Rotenone is considered one of the most environmentally benign toxicants available
for fisheries management. Fish are acutely sensitive to rotenone poisoning, quickly
absorbing the toxin across the gill surface and dying within hours at concentrations
below 1 ppm, although individual species sensitivities vary widely. Aquatic inverte-
brates are generally less sensitive than fish, but it will cause significant collateral
loss of invertebrate fauna, although invertebrate populations quickly recover.
Humans and wildlife are comparatively insensitive to rotenone, which provides a
large safety margin between concentrations required to kill fish and those that may
prove harmful to non-target, non-aquatic organisms. Rotenone can be applied to
standing or flowing waters as a generally dispersed toxicant, either in liquid or
powdered form, or as formulated baits to target nuisance species. Rotenone is
chemically unstable and breaks down rapidly in the environment, yielding water-
soluble non-toxic products. It is readily metabolised to non-toxic excretable
substances in the bodies of vertebrates receiving a sub-lethal dose. Rotenone is not
considered to be carcinogenic. Recent experimental findings linking it to
Parkinsonian effects seem unlikely to occur under normal uses. Cost and availability
limit the use of rotenone to relatively small water bodies.

Rotenone is non-persistent in the environment, being
quickly broken down by light and heat. It does not accumulate in animals and is
readily metabolised and excreted.

Recent research interest in rotenone stems mainly from
biochemical interest in its highly specific action in selectively inhibiting
mitochondrial activity and its possible anticancer properties.


Read the full text, and judge it's dangers for yourself. It is not the same as agricultural workers being exposed regularly for years (as with unprotected pesticide use).

http://www.doc.govt.nz/documents/science-and-technical/SFC211.pdf
Interesting read, surprised to see that one of the advantages is "low cost" as the cost is often cited as a reason that it's not used more.
I'm not saying it's not a possible solution to the Dragon Lake problem, but having links to Parkinson's could make it a hard sell to the homeowners/residents on the lake. Even if the links are still being investigated, and are probably only a concern for those directly handling the chemical.
Having a crew show up in "bio-hazard suits" doesn't always instill confidence in "Don't worry it's harmless" notices from the government, lol.
It's a problem with no easy solution, but if it's cost effective and safe, and will work on a body of water like Dragon, rotenone might be a possible solution. Now getting the government to act, well....that might be the biggest hurdle.
 
The Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) has confirmed the presence of koi herpesvirus disease (KHVD) in cultured koi carp (Cyprinus carpio koi) in British Columbia (B.C.).

The disease detection was associated with an import of koi from Israel by a wholesaler who distributed fish to greenhouses, pet stores and garden centres within B.C. for sale to private individuals. As a result of this detection, the import of all susceptible species of aquatic animals from Israel for the following end uses will be suspended until further notice:

• aquarium – commercial;
• aquarium – private;
• outdoor holding unit – commercial; and
• outdoor holding unit – private.

Notice to industry: http://inspection.gc.ca/eng/1503605707023/1503605707408
 
Back
Top