Eating Your Catch

Discussion in 'Saltwater Fishing Forum' started by Rain City, Jun 25, 2020.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Rain City

    Rain City Crew Member

    So clearly everyone does this but isn't it illegal? Maybe just one of those things we're not supposed to plaster all over the internet?
     
  2. advTHXance

    advTHXance Well-Known Member

    Im not sure I understand? Are u suggesting its illegal to eat fish youve legally caught?
     
  3. wildmanyeah

    wildmanyeah Crew Member

    You can eat your catch on your boat but daily limits still apply.
     
    CRGreg and G-Auto like this.
  4. Reeltime

    Reeltime Well-Known Member

    Can't enjoy this what the hell lol go ahead give me a ticket.... while your drooling
    2048EFEF-2E0E-4831-BE83-C522DD76D5B8.JPG
     
    sly_karma, Tydey, Unreel and 13 others like this.
  5. noluck

    noluck Well-Known Member

    daily limit is what you have not eaten and are in possession off
     
    Stizzla, Dogbreath and ILHG like this.
  6. Rain City

    Rain City Crew Member

    That's different because it's sweet lol :cool:
     
    Reeltime likes this.
  7. Rain City

    Rain City Crew Member

    You see there it is again. Total confusion.
     
  8. Rain City

    Rain City Crew Member

    No like if you're on a trip and you catch your limit in the morning, eat one for lunch and then go back out and get another one because you're now no longer in "possession" of that fish.
     
    sasqman likes this.
  9. noluck

    noluck Well-Known Member

    it is different if it has no be marked on your licence
     
  10. wildmanyeah

    wildmanyeah Crew Member

    you can't catch 4 sockeye eat them all and then catch 4 more. Daily limits still apply to eaten food.
     
    Unreel, nicnat, 1marko and 4 others like this.
  11. Pineapple Express

    Pineapple Express Well-Known Member

    Dude, you're wrong here. You can't catch a fish, BBQ it on the boat/beach, and then go back and start again.
     
    CRGreg likes this.
  12. advTHXance

    advTHXance Well-Known Member

    But if you recorded your catch correctly on your licence youd still be tubbed out for the day and unable to legally retain another fish.

    I suppose it gets a little less clearcut for species that dont require documentation.

    I would also argue that if you go out and catch your limit in the morning, no matter what you fill your belly with at lunchtime youve probably killed enough fish for the day.
     
  13. Gong Show

    Gong Show Well-Known Member

    We go to the West Coast annually.
    Usually we catch a little ping pong hali.
    We keep it as an under for one of us that day and mark our licence.
    We eat it that night and for breakfast the next day.
    We try and fish the rest of the trip, so we come back with an over and an under each.
    We do not go home to our residence in between.

    My take, daily limits always apply, but once eaten, they are not counted towards your multi day possession limit.
     
  14. Rain City

    Rain City Crew Member

    So isn't that why the rule is you must transport your catch to your regular place of residence so there's no grey area? Like you can't pressure can fish whatsoever while away for this reason.
     
  15. CRGreg

    CRGreg Active Member

    WRONG... Daily Limit is what you caught today.. doesnt matter if you've eaten it, given it away or whatever, You can only catch your limit. It might be tough to prove... but its illegal and unethical.

    CRGreg
     
    nicnat, Brett, DMCK and 3 others like this.
  16. G-Auto

    G-Auto Active Member

    There are rules to how it is transported to your residence not that it must be transported to your residence. Once you can or cut up fish you can tell how many fish there are and/or how big they are. Gong Show has posted the most correct answer in my opinion.
     
  17. advTHXance

    advTHXance Well-Known Member

    Those rules were imposed years ago because people would literally set up their own personal smokeshacks and canneries at fish camps and kill/can/smoke as much as they could. Your daily limit is a static number and has nothing to do with the fish you eat during the course of the day. The possession limit is generally twice the daily limit (though not always).

    As a hypothetical, lets say youre on a week long fishing trip, and you tub out the first 2 days. Your possession limit has been reached. In order to retain any fish legally on the 3rd day you would have to eat some of whats in your possession. Alternatively you could drive the fish home to your legal residence and clear your possession limit. If the fish isnt at your legal residence its still considered part of your possession limit.
     
    Brett and CRGreg like this.
  18. wildmanyeah

    wildmanyeah Crew Member

    For example while on a trip

    1. day catch 4 sockeye eat 4 sockeye
    2. second day catch 4 put on ice
    3. third day catch 4 put on ice

    return home with possession limit of 8 salmon.
     
    Brett and CRGreg like this.
  19. Rain City

    Rain City Crew Member

    So what's stopping someone from dropping all their fish off at the processor and having at it again?
     
  20. zurk

    zurk Active Member

    is that lobster ? where the heck do you catch lobster in BC ? its not native.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page