Saxe Point
Well-Known Member
I finally have sort of figured things out and did okay for halibut this year. But in reviewing the current tables for 2020, I noticed a couple of things that raise some questions. Hoping people chime in with some answers.
First, in comparing Murray's Tables with the Borsboom Tables (free off the internet) , there seems to be more differences than overlap between them. At a halibut seminar in Langford I attended a number of years ago, the presenters said that the fishable currents are 16-21 and 37-43 in the Current Atlas. The Borsboom Tables have a lot more currents listed in these ranges than Murray's. I believe both sets of tables are generated using a mathematical formula (the same one?), so I'm wondering why the differences? I have found the Borsboom tables to be very accurate and reliable, and rarely rely on Murray's anymore. I've never bought Washburn's (now called Waggoners). What are your understandings of and experiences with these different tables?
Second, and perhaps more important, do most of you limit your halibut fishing (around Sooke and Victoria) to only the 16-21/37-43 currents shown on the tables, or do you fish other numbers as well? If so, which ones? I find that even during the "16-21/37-43" windows, the currents will be barely fishable at the start of the window, but then improve quickly to almost perfect as you get to slack tide, after which they then start to speed up again. This is why I don't bother trying any other current windows.
Thanks in advance for your wisdom.
First, in comparing Murray's Tables with the Borsboom Tables (free off the internet) , there seems to be more differences than overlap between them. At a halibut seminar in Langford I attended a number of years ago, the presenters said that the fishable currents are 16-21 and 37-43 in the Current Atlas. The Borsboom Tables have a lot more currents listed in these ranges than Murray's. I believe both sets of tables are generated using a mathematical formula (the same one?), so I'm wondering why the differences? I have found the Borsboom tables to be very accurate and reliable, and rarely rely on Murray's anymore. I've never bought Washburn's (now called Waggoners). What are your understandings of and experiences with these different tables?
Second, and perhaps more important, do most of you limit your halibut fishing (around Sooke and Victoria) to only the 16-21/37-43 currents shown on the tables, or do you fish other numbers as well? If so, which ones? I find that even during the "16-21/37-43" windows, the currents will be barely fishable at the start of the window, but then improve quickly to almost perfect as you get to slack tide, after which they then start to speed up again. This is why I don't bother trying any other current windows.
Thanks in advance for your wisdom.