I think that you would want to go up island a bit to get into some different fishing from what you have been doing here in Vancouver in the years you have been here. If requirement #1 is overwhelmingly the criteria, then I would say Campbell River. You are right on some good salmon fishing in town, but close enough to Nootka and Port Hardy that it is not too big a deal to tow the boat to those places if you want to fish for hali or other ground fish. Given the type of boat I know you are after, Nootka seems like the perfect destination trip for those times when you want to venture outside our new home base. Protected even on the windy days, but offshore fishing available on those days when the wind is calm. The only down side of CR is that its not near to major health facilities. If I had a choice number 2, it would be Nanaimo or somewhere close to it. Still good fishing right at home and if you want a special trip, haul the boat to Barkley Sound.