Pressure Canning - Why are there duds?

Rain City

Crew Member
I'm losing two or three per batch. I do 24 small jars in a 18 quart canner. Very diligent about cleanliness and timing. No consistent "row" losing jars.

Over tighening?
Under tightening?
Over filling?
Under filling?
Dirty lid?
Too many jars?
WTF?!
 
Dude, it's the universe telling you to eat those ones right now.
Don't disappoint the universe.
Well that's the usual end result. Only last night I passed out after finishing the first batch and left it all on the counter. Woke up to 3 wasted jars. Wife got mad. Doing 10 sockeye from superstore.
She was that Chinese lady buying up all the fish on sale.
 
Yup that's it. Three batches, three duds in each batch. I can't figure it out.
 
I always buy new disks, boil on high, use tongs to put them on, then tight, very tight. Rarely loose any.
So why does every recipe say not to boil them and to not overtighten? Starting to sound like DFO regs here.
 
As Steve says always new lids...and make sure that your rim has been cleaned well ;) You know what i'm talking about.
And leave the proper head space, that is key...when it is processing, there is lots of activity in the jar and it needs the room at the top.
 
As stated always start with new snap lids, even at that boil the lids in water vinegar and leave them in the hot water only taking them out as you put them on, this will require a set of tongs. Keep a the pot with hot water and vinegar mixer and lids next to the jars. After the jars are filled and as you put the snap lids on wipe each jar rim with the hot water vinegar mixer this will remove any oils from the jar rim and ensure a tight seal. Do not fully tighten the lids until after they have cooled and sealed just prior to storage.

Good luck.
 
Thanks guys. I checked the duds and what I've determined (I hope) is that the lids just weren't centered very well. I was doing 6 cases of jars at once and I kind of just tossed the lids on there willy nilly. Figured the rings would center them better. Next time I'll make sure the lids are perfectly centered. Still weird that it was exactly 3 per batch of 24.
 
Thanks guys. I checked the duds and what I've determined (I hope) is that the lids just weren't centered very well. I was doing 6 cases of jars at once and I kind of just tossed the lids on there willy nilly. Figured the rings would center them better. Next time I'll make sure the lids are perfectly centered. Still weird that it was exactly 3 per batch of 24.

At least you are consistent.
And by that I mean you deliver a good story on every thread!
 
Dirty lids and dirty rims.

after I fill the jars, I clean the rims with paper town soaked in vinegar.

not to say im perfect last 30 jars i did I had one jar crack and one not seal!
 
Last edited:
When we do our pickles we always have the jars rim side down, on cookie sheet with water in the oven at 300. Lids are always in a pot at a constant boil. Usually have a 99%ish success
 
I do it for the people. To be honest when @Stizzla showed up it really took the pressure off ;)
Awww. When I saw I was mentioned in a threads with the word “dud” in it I was sure you were going to be trash talking me.
Maybe you’re a becoming a nice guy after all!
 
As Steve says always new lids...and make sure that your rim has been cleaned well ;) You know what i'm talking about.
And leave the proper head space, that is key...when it is processing, there is lots of activity in the jar and it needs the room at the top.
A dude named “Get bent” taking about “cleaning your rim” and “proper head”?! This thread is nasty
 
I checked the duds and what I've determined (I hope) is that the lids just weren't centered very well..... I kind of just tossed the lids on there willy nilly. Figured the rings would center them better....
I make freezer jam and this is what I've found luckily it makes no difference since it's just frozen jam but I have seen some messes I created because of fatigue and inattention (working late at night).
 
i hope you are using a pressure cooker and not a hot water bath.
they cooked so put the poorly sealed ones in the fridge right away, and any others the lid is not sunken down, and they will be edible or the lid will further depress and seal.
 
i hope you are using a pressure cooker and not a hot water bath.
they cooked so put the poorly sealed ones in the fridge right away, and any others the lid is not sunken down, and they will be edible or the lid will further depress and seal.
Yes of course.
 
I was loosing a similar amount each round. Started snuggling the lids pretty tight...dont lose any because of the seal now.

Lose some because of cracking...but that's just me trusting weak jars too much.
 
Small chips on jar edge and bad jars some are not level just threw one out today that was sealed two years and the lid let loose the jar was off level
 
Back
Top