I had been working my dragonfly nymph back and forth
along the bottom of the lake for about twenty minutes
with nary a tug and I was becoming a bit suspect of
the fishing prospects for the rest of the day. Just
when I was about to give up I felt the familiar slow
but solid thud of life at the other end of my line.
I set the hook hard and tightened up, only to have the
fish force me into relinquishing fly line at several
feet per second.
Luckily, the run was short and we settled into a tug of war
for the next five minutes: me trying to gain line, it trying
to break free of the insect that now held it hostage. After
the first run, the fish did a series of rolls followed by
a number of bangs against the leader with its tail. The hook
held and I gained some line. It then used its sheer weight
and power to take more line from the reel and followed this
with more violent twists and rolls. As time wore on she became
tired (as did my arm), finally allowing me to raise her head
out of the water, and I skated her towards my bellyboat and
into the open net. My partner Ian had been watching nearby,
and after taking a few photos we estimated her size at about
three pounds and then released her.
No, it wasn’t a rainbow, it was
a brook trout, and we weren’t fishing in the Laurentians,
northern Manitoba, or the Nipigon area of Ontario. We
were fishing in Black Lake near Kamloops, British Columbia.
Surprised? . . . you shouldn’t be. British Columbia
now has some of the finest brook trout fishing to be
found anywhere in the world.
The brook trout, also known as the speckled trout or
squaretail, is one of God's most beautiful contributions
to this earth. Its lovely red spots and blue halos,
combined with orange fins edged in black and white take
my breath away every time I see one. It doesn't put
up the fight that the rainbow does, but it makes up
for it in tenacity, endurance, and bulk.
The square tail (which is actually a char and, therefore,
a relative of the lake trout and Dolly Varden) fights like
a chinook salmon, preferring to stay deep, rolling and making
short, strong runs, whereas the rainbow likes long exhausting
runs followed by aerial acrobatics. Inch for inch, the brook
trout will also outweigh a rainbow by as much as one and a
half times. Besides being a great sport fish, I also believe
that they are the best tasting freshwater game fish an angler
can come by.
Ontario and Quebec have long been noted for their trophy
brook trout fishing and have many records to prove it. What
many anglers do not realize is that this great game fish has
moved out west, with surprising success. I did some research
into the stocking of square tails in B.C., and with help of
a number of fisheries biologists in the B.C. Ministry of Environment,
I dug up all the records dating back to the first recorded
stockings of these fish. The records indicate introductions
of brookies in a number of streams as early as 1908 (mostly
on Vancouver Island) and discussions with the biologists revealed
that there were earlier introductions, but no one is left
alive to tell where they were placed or when. It was all incredibly
Over the years brook trout have been introduced to more and
more lakes and streams throughout British Columbia. I asked
why the provincial government had decided to officially continue
the stocking program after the first unauthorized introductions
when we have such a large stocking program for rainbows, especially
the world renowned Kamloops strain. The answer was simple:
brook trout are a hardier species and can withstand greater
extremes in temperature as well as lower levels of oxygen
than can the rainbow or cutthroat trout. This allows the Ministry
of Environment to stock brook trout in waters that are prone
to winterkill. These fish are, in many cases, able to survive
where the native species would not. Lakes and streams that
are being considered for brook trout stocking are carefully
checked to ensure that the char cannot escape into other waterways.
Should this happen, they could threaten the native fish populations;
brook trout have the same feeding habits as native trout.
Records show that introductions of speckled trout in B.C.
have escalated from a few hundred fish in a half dozen or
so lakes and streams in 1908 (the precise numbers are not
known) to well over 1,000,000 fry and yearlings spread throughout
the province. In the 1930's, Spectacle Lake on Vancouver Island
was utilized as the main egg rearing facility for the province.
It has since been closed down and replaced by Aylmer Lake,
near Kamloops, which has a year round angling closure. Aylmer
now produces the majority of brook trout for the province.
Over these many years, this program has produced some excellent
freshwater sport fishing where none was available before.
Many of the lakes that now support brook trout also support
rainbows, but it has been my experience that neither species
reaches exceptional proportions when dwelling together. On
the other hand, numerous lakes are populated strictly with
speckled trout and some have produced exceptionally large
fish in excess of six pounds.
An interesting thing that I have noticed as I have pursued
this fish across the southern half of the province is that
they tend to change their overall shade to suit their environment.
That's not to say they change quickly like a chameleon, but
over time their colour tones appear to take on the shade best
suited to their surroundings. The fish I have caught in Spectacle
Lake all exhibit a definite dark shade that blends in with
the tea coloured water and mud bottom of the lake. The same
applies to the brookies I have caught in little Rose Lake
near Kamloops. Other speckles that I have caught in lakes
such as Black Lake (very near Rose) have shown much less colour
and a lot more silver. Black Lake has a white marl bottom
and very clear water. The silver shade would naturally provide
better camouflage in these conditions. I don't know if anyone
has scientifically investigated this, but if you travel around
in pursuit of this fish you will see what I mean.
Fishing for brookies in B.C. is much the same as fishing
for them anywhere else. They like small lures such as the
Panther Martin and will come to a gang troll as well, but
my preferred method of fishing for them is with a fly. When
a hatch is on, these fish rise nearly as readily as rainbows
and will take a well-presented dry fly with enthusiasm. The
best success I have had, however, is fishing a black leech
pattern or a dragonfly or damselfly nymph near the bottom.
A slow retrieve seems to be most effective, and these char
tend to mouth the fly instead of hitting it hard like do rainbows.
Combine this soft take with their bony mouths and you will
find that you have to be ready to set the hook when you think
you have snagged bottom, and you must ensure that your hook
is razor sharp or you’ll end up losing a lot more than
As a member of the char family, brook trout spawn in the
fall. Thus, you are best to fish for them in the spring when
they are firm and active. Summer however, can be highly productive
for squaretails as well, certainly much better than the rainbow
fishing. Brook trout tolerate the warmer water better and
continue to feed when rainbows turn off of theirs. Winter
can also produce some excellent fishing. Ice fishing for brook
trout has really caught on in the past decade and the provincial
fisheries have been hard pressed to keep stocks up in lakes
where ice fishing is popular.
Another point to keep in mind is that speckled trout
tend to school, sometimes in very large numbers. If
you are prospecting a new lake and luck into a fish
take note of where you picked it up and at what depth.
If there is a major break in the bottom topography,
or downed trees, etc., chances are that the school is
holding in and around the break. Work the area over
at different depths and you will more than likely pick
up more fish from the same spot.
The brook trout is well known as a meat fish. Its
value as a game fish is renowned in eastern Canada but
has not yet come into its own in B.C. due in part to
western anglers' preoccupation with the Kamloops and
Gerard rainbows. Slowly but surely it is emerging as
a very viable alternative to the more traditional fresh
water game fish. It is excellent table fare and, combined
with its biological differences from the true trout,
I am sure that the future of this fish in the west is
bright. So as the old saying goes . . . “if you
want good brook trout fishing, go west young fisherman.”
Bill Luscombe has been hunting and fishing for
most of his 42 years. He has been flyfishing for 20
years. He instructs flyfishing, and has done so for
the past 12 years. He also instructs the federal FSET
firearms course and the BC CORE hunter training course.
He is an award-winning outdoor writer and has been writing
freelance since 1987. He has been published in BC Sport
Fishing Magazine, Outdoor Edge, BC Outdoors, Western
Sportsman, Island Fish Finder, and the BC Hunting Guide.
Bill Luscombe was born an army brat and raised in
Ladner (Delta, BC) where he was raised hunting waterfowl
and pheasants. He presently resides in North Cowichan
on southern Vancouver Island where he has lived and
worked full time as a professional forester since 1982.
He presently works in Nanaimo for the BC Forest Service
and continue to write the fly-fishing column for BC
Sport Fishing Magazine as well as contributing articles
freelance to various outdoor magazines in western Canada.
Bill Luscombe is also a BC Director of the Northwest
Outdoor Writers Association. "Catching fish is not hard.
You simply need to understand what makes them tick.
If you think like a fish, you will catch fish. It’s
as simple as that."- Bill Luscombe
Previous Articles by Bill Luscombe:
To visit saltwater flyfishing patterns by Bill Luscombe,
For more information about Bill Luscombe and his available
courses visit his home page at: